How Long Does a Personal Injury Case Take?
You’ve slipped and fallen while walking through your favorite restaurant, gotten into a car crash, or suffered another type of personal injury—and now you’re just ready for the whole process to be over with. You need money for your outstanding medical bills, and you were probably out of work for a while, recovering from your accident injuries, and are behind on your household bills.
Each case is different, and the personal injury claim process for each case varies depending on how willing the defendant is to settle, how much evidence there is in your favor, and whether your case is going to trial. We have found that working with an experienced New Jersey personal injury attorney can help streamline the process and keep the case moving forward without unnecessary delays or learning curve delays.
Estimated Timelines in the Personal Injury Claim Process
If you’re wondering how long a personal injury claim takes to settle, here are the general timelines based on case complexity:
- Straightforward cases: Can be settled in six months to one year. Liability in these cases is clear, the plaintiff’s injuries are minor (and they’ll likely make a full recovery), and their damages are modest
- Moderate cases: Usually settle in one to two years. Liability may be contested or unclear, the plaintiff’s injuries may be more serious, or the value of the plaintiff’s damages may exceed the defendant’s insurance cap
- Complex cases: Can take two years or longer to settle. These are cases in which liability may be disputed, the plaintiff’s injuries may be severe and disabling, there may be an unusual point of law to resolve, multiple parties are involved, or the case is almost definitely going to trial
So if you’re trying to understand how long a personal injury claim takes to settle, most cases in New Jersey fall within this six-month to two-year window. Remember, though, once you settle your case, you cannot reopen it to seek additional damages if it turns out you have complications from your injuries, or the settlement isn’t enough to cover all your losses. This is why it is vital you are confident in the settlement you are being offered and why it is best ot have an experienced advocate on your side.
Let’s dive deeper into the factors that influence the length of time your case will take to resolve.
Factor #1: How Severe the Plaintiff’s Injuries Are
Cases in which the plaintiff is severely injured and requires ongoing or follow-up medical treatment take longer to settle because it takes more time to calculate the full extent of their economic damages.
As the injured party, you’re entitled to full compensation for all your medical bills and all lost wages from the time you were unable to work due to your injuries.
Some plaintiffs are so severely injured that they cannot live independently or sustain gainful employment. In these cases, their damages can include the cost of accommodations in a long-term care facility, like a nursing home, and their loss of earning potential. These high-value claims typically take upwards of a year to settle. They may require testimony from medical and economic experts to clarify the extent of the plaintiff’s injuries, the long-term cost of care, future medical damages, and the value of the plaintiff’s loss of earning power.
Factor #2: How Many Parties are Involved
Your case may involve more than one defendant. Semi-truck accident cases, product liability claims, and premises liability cases often have more than one defendant. It’s usually the person primarily responsible for causing the accident, and a secondary defendant, such as their employer, who may be held responsible under the legal concept of vicarious liability.
It takes longer to build multiple cases against multiple defendants. The plaintiff’s lawyer must establish that each defendant owed the plaintiff a duty of care and failed to fulfill it, leading to the accident and the plaintiff’s injuries. Each case must be supported by objective evidence and a compelling legal argument proving each defendant’s liability.
Or, perhaps you’re involved in a class action or mass tort lawsuit. These cases involve multiple plaintiffs who were all injured in the same manner and suffered similar losses due to the negligence of a common defendant. Dangerous-drug and consumer-product liability cases are the most common types of personal injury claims litigated as class actions or mass torts. These cases easily take two years or longer to resolve.
Factor #3: How Much Evidence is Available
In the personal injury claim process, gathering evidence, medical records, and witness statements can take time, especially if there are many documents to review or parties to contact. If there isn’t much evidence readily available in your case, then your lawyer may have to enlist the services of a private investigator to gather more.
Multiple witnesses may need to be deposed (questioned by one party’s lawyer under oath for the purposes of gathering evidence). This can take time, too, especially in mass tort and class action lawsuits.
Factor #4: How Clear Liability is, or Whether Liability is Disputed
Some claims are pretty straightforward, and it’s pretty clear that the defendant is responsible for the accident. When liability is clear, a case can settle fairly quickly, as the defendant’s insurance company is unlikely to push for a trial they’re pretty sure they’ll lose.
In many personal injury claims, though, liability is contested. Maybe the defendant agrees that they contributed some of the blame for the accident, but alleges that the plaintiff also contributed some of the blame. This comes up frequently in states with modified comparative negligence rules for personal injury claims, like New Jersey.
Modified comparative liability rules permit plaintiffs to recover damages if they contributed less than 50% of the blame for the accident, but their settlement is reduced by the percentage of blame they contributed. If the defendant can shift the majority of the blame, even if it’s just 51%, to the plaintiff, then they don’t have to pay damages. Or, even if the defendant is still partly liable for the accident, they will be on the hook for less if they can prove the plaintiff contributed a larger share of the blame.
Factor #5: Willingness of the Defendant to Settle Out of Court
The overwhelming majority of personal injury claims—some statistics suggest up to 95%—settle out of court. This happens through negotiations between the two parties (or more often, their lawyers) or via an alternative dispute resolution process like mediation or arbitration.
Settlement negotiations usually take less time to complete than taking the case to trial. The defendant’s insurance company (auto, homeowners, business liability, etc.) usually pays the claim, not the defendant themselves, so often negotiations will depend on what the insurer is willing to pay.
Factor #6: Whether Your Case Goes to Trial
Personal injury cases go to trial when liability is contested, when one side refuses to settle, or when a plaintiff’s attorney believes that the defendant should be assessed punitive damages (which are usually only awarded by a jury).
Personal injury trials can be as short as a week or can last (if it’s a class action or mass tort) several months. The lead-up to the trial can easily be a year. In New Jersey, the discovery phase (evidence gathering and the exchange of documents and information between both sides) for civil trials can last 6 to 12 months. And you’ll also have to wait for a trial date to become available, which may not be until several months after you file your suit.
This is one of the reasons why the length of a personal injury claim’s settlement varies so widely—cases that go to trial take significantly longer.
Settle Your Personal Injury Case Fast with Skilled Legal Advocacy
Have you been hurt in an accident you didn’t cause and need to know your legal options? The attorneys at Costello Law Firm represent injured people like you in civil claims for damages. We seek full and fair compensation for your injuries, and we don’t waste time taking action to get you the compensation you deserve. Our firm handles all the legal matters necessary to move your claim forward, keeping your best interests in mind with every step. Call our firm today or fill out our secure online contact form to schedule your complimentary consultation.
Frequently Asked Questions
How long does a personal injury claim take to settle in New Jersey?
Most claims settle between six months and two years, depending on injury severity, the clarity of liability, cooperation from the insurance company, and whether the case goes to trial.
What steps are involved in the personal injury claim process?
The process typically includes medical treatment, investigation, evidence gathering, demand letters, negotiation, potential mediation, and—if needed—a trial. Each step can add time based on complexity. Get a free case review and allow one of our experienced NJ lawyers to review the details of your claim.
Why do some personal injury cases take longer to resolve than others?
Cases often take longer when injuries are severe, multiple parties are involved, liability is disputed, evidence is limited, or the defendant refuses to offer a reasonable settlement.
Will hiring a personal injury lawyer speed up my case?
Yes. An experienced attorney helps move your claim forward efficiently by gathering evidence quickly, negotiating early, avoiding procedural mistakes, and applying pressure when the insurer delays.
This article is intended for informational purposes only and is not to be considered as legal advice. For any legal matter, you should always contact a licensed attorney to get a legal opinion.